Appropriateness and Transparency: Measuring Outcomes to Improve the Quality of Surgical Care in France
Seance of wednesday 30 september 2026 (La chirurgie en 2035)
DOI number : 10.26299/drzj-fg21/emem.2026.28.03
Abstract
Background. According to the OECD, nearly 20% of healthcare spending is avoidable. Yet, unlike Anglo-Saxon countries, France assesses processes rather than outcomes: hospital certification, physician accreditation and continuing professional development (DPC) inform neither patients about their risk nor surgeons about their performance.
Findings. Outcome indicators are nevertheless already published by “Visuchir”, and national health insurance data reveal unwarranted variations in practice (bariatric surgery, thyroidectomy, surgical approaches). Team competence is undermined by activity thresholds in cancer surgery that are among the lowest in Europe, by reliance on locum physicians and by the heterogeneous qualifications of non-EU-trained doctors (PADHUE).
Proposals. A virtuous circle of continuous quality improvement must rest on outcomes: national health data (SNDS) and registries, with widespread use of PROMs; binding guidelines issued by professional councils and the HAS for high-stakes procedures; care pathways coordinated by general practitioners; annual publication of risk-adjusted outcomes by hospital and by team, linked to activity authorisations; a national quality-monitoring platform bringing together professionals and patients; and reformed funding (bundled, episode- or pathway-based payments) tied to explicit quality and appropriateness criteria. Raising activity thresholds and standardising surgeons’ qualifications are the necessary corollaries. Transparency will extend into the operating room: the “black box” and AI-driven analysis of human factors will be transformative only if the paradigm shifts from blame to performance, and if teams come to regard the analysis of their own errors as routine.
Conclusion. Quality cannot be decreed: it must be measured, compared and made public.
Prof. Alain Bernard – Dijon University Hospital (CHU de Dijon)
Findings. Outcome indicators are nevertheless already published by “Visuchir”, and national health insurance data reveal unwarranted variations in practice (bariatric surgery, thyroidectomy, surgical approaches). Team competence is undermined by activity thresholds in cancer surgery that are among the lowest in Europe, by reliance on locum physicians and by the heterogeneous qualifications of non-EU-trained doctors (PADHUE).
Proposals. A virtuous circle of continuous quality improvement must rest on outcomes: national health data (SNDS) and registries, with widespread use of PROMs; binding guidelines issued by professional councils and the HAS for high-stakes procedures; care pathways coordinated by general practitioners; annual publication of risk-adjusted outcomes by hospital and by team, linked to activity authorisations; a national quality-monitoring platform bringing together professionals and patients; and reformed funding (bundled, episode- or pathway-based payments) tied to explicit quality and appropriateness criteria. Raising activity thresholds and standardising surgeons’ qualifications are the necessary corollaries. Transparency will extend into the operating room: the “black box” and AI-driven analysis of human factors will be transformative only if the paradigm shifts from blame to performance, and if teams come to regard the analysis of their own errors as routine.
Conclusion. Quality cannot be decreed: it must be measured, compared and made public.
Prof. Alain Bernard – Dijon University Hospital (CHU de Dijon)

